All chapters

Genomics Technologies

beginner

Sequencing Generations Comparison

Three Generations of Sequencing

๐Ÿงช1st GenSanger | 600-1000 bp | >99.9% accuracy | 1-96 reads/run | Gold standard for confirmation
โšก2nd GenIllumina/MGI | 150-300 bp | >99.9% accuracy | Billions reads/run | Clinical WES standard
๐Ÿ”ฎ3rd GenPacBio/Nanopore | 10-100 kb | 85-99.9% | SV detection | Methylation | Phasing

Sanger Sequencing (1st Generation)

Developed by Frederick Sanger in 1977, who won the Nobel Prize for it. Uses chain-terminating dideoxynucleotides (ddNTPs) - analogues of normal dNTPs that lack the 3'-OH group needed for chain extension. When a ddNTP is incorporated, elongation stops, producing a ladder of fragments of different lengths. Capillary electrophoresis separates by size; fluorescent dye colours identify each base.

Despite being 50 years old, Sanger sequencing remains the gold standard for single-variant confirmation in clinical labs. Any pathogenic variant identified by WES or NGS that will influence clinical management must be confirmed by Sanger before reporting.

  • Read length: 600โ€“1000 bp (longest of any sequencing method)
  • Accuracy: >99.9% raw - the most accurate sequencing available for a single read
  • Throughput: 1โ€“96 reads per run (very low - not scalable to whole genomes)
  • Cost: ~$5โ€“10 per reaction (cheap per reaction, expensive per genome)
  • Turnaround: 1โ€“2 days (primer design + PCR + sequencing)
  • Clinical use: confirm WES/NGS findings before reporting; targeted family testing; confirm pathogenic variants in known disease genes
  • Limitation: cannot detect CNVs, structural variants, or variants below ~20% allele frequency
code
# Typical Sanger confirmation workflow
# 1. Design primers flanking the variant (Primer3, NCBI Primer-BLAST)
#    Target: 200-400 bp amplicon; variant in middle third
# 2. PCR amplification from patient DNA
# 3. Cleanup (ExoSAP-IT or gel purification)
# 4. Cycle sequencing with BigDye Terminator v3.1
# 5. Capillary electrophoresis on ABI 3730xl
# 6. Interpret chromatogram with FinchTV or Sequencher

# Example: Confirming BRCA1 c.5266dupC
# Primer F: 5'-CTTACCTGTTTTATGCATTTT-3'
# Primer R: 5'-TTTCATAAGAAAATTTTGAGCAGTT-3'
# Expected: heterozygous insertion peak visible in chromatogram

Next Generation Sequencing (2nd Generation)

Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) revolutionised genomics from 2007 onwards by enabling massively parallel sequencing - millions of DNA fragments sequenced simultaneously in a single run. The key innovation was "sequencing by synthesis" combined with bridge amplification on a flow cell surface, generating millions of clusters each reading the same fragment.

The cost of sequencing a human genome dropped from $3 billion (2003) to under $200 (2023), following a trajectory faster than Moore's Law. This democratised genomics, making clinical WES affordable at โ‚น15,000โ€“30,000 in India today.

Platform Comparison

  • Illumina (NovaSeq, NextSeq, MiSeq) - 150โ€“300 bp reads, >99.9% accuracy, most widely used, ~$1/Gb
  • MGI/BGI (DNBSEQ) - similar to Illumina, lower cost, used in large population studies
  • Ion Torrent (Thermo Fisher) - semiconductor sequencing, fast runs, higher error in homopolymers
  • Complete Genomics - proprietary combinatorial probe-anchor synthesis, population-scale

Long-Read Sequencing (3rd Generation)

  • PacBio HiFi (SMRT) - 15โ€“25 kb reads, >99.9% HiFi accuracy, methylation detection, $10โ€“15/Gb
  • Oxford Nanopore (MinION, PromethION) - real-time sequencing, up to Mb-length reads, ~85โ€“98% raw accuracy
  • Advantages over short reads: resolves complex SVs, repeats, phasing, full-length transcripts
  • Disadvantage: higher error rate in raw reads (Nanopore), higher cost per Gb (PacBio)

Library Preparation Key Concepts

  • Fragmentation: sonication or enzymatic to target insert size (150โ€“300 bp for WES)
  • End-repair & A-tailing: creates blunt ends then adds 3' adenine overhang
  • Adapter ligation: adds platform-specific sequences with unique molecular identifiers (UMIs)
  • PCR amplification: 8โ€“12 cycles; too many cycles creates duplicates
  • Capture (WES): biotinylated probes hybridise to exonic regions, pull down with streptavidin beads
  • Size selection: removes adapter dimers; typically 200โ€“400 bp final library size